Bharat Central Pensioners Confederation

Proceedings of the meeting of All Pensioners Organisations held at Chennai on 14/06/2014 to discuss and finalise the Common Memorandum:

R.L.Bhattacharyya Vice Chairman of BCPC Presided

Condolence by two minutes silence observed.

S.K.Vyas: Last time when 6^th CPC was constituted, we had similar meeting of all Pensioners Organisations and submitted a common memorandum for limited purposes. Before 6^th CPC was set up some pensioners organisations, particularly AICCPA, RREW Secunderaabad, BPS and NCCPA came together to form a steering committee for the purpose of drafting a common memorandum. Accordingly a draft was prepared by the committee and that was circulated and then a meeting held at Bangalore and Hyderabad and subsequently in Delhi had finalised the memorandum to be submitted to 6^th CPC. After the job was over, the sponsors of the steering committee thought why not convert this steering committee into a spex level organisation of pensioners. Then a convention was held at Kolkata in which BCPC was constituted. Next meeting at Delhi BCPC Came into existence with bylaw etc. Shyam Sunder was the founder Secretay General of BCPC and due to his illness he resigned and I am asked to officiate as BCPC SG. I was only a patron but still I was asked to accept. Thereafter the AGM of BCPC held at Delhi, it was decided that BCPC should initiate the process for finalising a common memorandum for 7^th CPC. Immediately we issued circular issued by BCPC for all to give their inputs and suggestions on the basis of which a draft common memorandum will be prepared. The CPC has announced that before 31.05.2014 memorandum to be submitted. JCM NC tried to get extended time. Before its fructification, some organisations have finalised their memorandum and submitted in order not to miss the bus. Still a common memorandum was prepared by us and placed in websites. WE asked all to send their suggestions modifications etc so that we can consider all such suggestions. So this meeting is called.

Generally response to such initiative  is sluggish. Still 20 organisations sent their suggestions. We have this memorandum that we will take up the suggestions one by one and decide whether we can incorporate them or not.

Amendments and suggestions received from different organisations were taken up one by one for discussion:

Nagpur:

Proposal made for once in 5 years revision of pension should be done: House agreed it and included in Chapter VIII Misc.

Grant of Interim Relief: 10% of Pay or pension as IR pending finalisation of Report. Staff side has demanded 25% of Pay. So should we accept 10% or fall in line with 20% as demanded by JCM Staff Side. On a discussion point it has been decided that no need to give a supplementary memorandum only on IR and Merger DA as like JCM because it will only be duplication of things. So we will demand 25% IR in Misc Chapter VIII.

VII CPC should submit its report simultaneously to Staff Side and Pensioners Organisation. This is not necessary as Pensioners Organisation is not recognised by Govt. All SCOVA members can ask for a copy when the report comes out. We need not ask as part of the Memorandum.

Nomination: Only one nominee is allowed by banks and Post Office. Why not more nominees allowed? This is not an issue coming under the purview of CPC. This need not be pressed.

Uniform PPOs: Agreed as at present PPOs draft are separate for department to department. We will raise it under Miscellaneous Chapter VIII for uniform PPO draft for all pensioners. This will be asked.

Pension should be net of Income tax: This is already in our memorandum.

Statutory body SCOVA: Three tiers SCOVA may not be a correct demand. But SCOVA as a statutory body and democratisation of representation may be demanded. The Para 8.12 is ok. We can demand change of nomenclature from SCOVA from Joint National Council of Pensioners Organisations. Comrade DG pointed out the need for two tier system one at National level (National Council) and another at Department level (Departmental Council). This is accepted and will be incorporated in the memorandum.

Disbursement of Pension at residences: Not necessary as ATMS are there near by residences as well as EMOs at the cost of Government is also there. The limit also we have asked to raise.

Family pension for 10 years at higher rates: Family is a unit. 3 unit families are reduced on retirement time and later if pensioner dies the family becomes one unit family. This is the reason for reduced pension. The 15 years for harness death is removed on suggestion from DG.

ITEF KKN:

Staff Side demanded that last pay drawn be taken as pension. Similarly we should demand that the pension should not be less than the minimum of the pay scale of the cadre in which he or she is retired. This amendment will be incorporated in para No: 3.9

AIFPA:

Merger of DA / IR: We have already incorporated.

Approved Chapter 1

Approved Chapter 2 but wanted to add Para 1.1 of BPS as Para 2.9 – This suggestion has been approved.

Chapter 3: Some paragraphs in Chapter VIII should be transferred to Chapter III. This suggestion is agreed upon.

Para No.12 of BPS need not be included – This is accepted.

BSNL pensioners as in Karnataka CCGPA memorandum – This was accepted.

Add a caption “Additions in Pension” above Table in Para 3.13 – Accepted.

Individual Pensioner letters received were also considered.  

Additional Pension – the house opinion is divided – we have indicated that it should be expressed in terms of % of LPD; Some opine that it should be on the % of pension. The following can be raised in the memorandum:

65 years age – 5% addition

70 years age – another 5% addition

75 years age – another 5% addition

80 years age – another 6% addition

85 years age – another 6% addition

90  years age – another 6% addition

Medicare: It can continue as it is written in our draft memorandum.

Para 5 of the BPS memorandum can be included under Chapter V (Family pension to secondary pensioners)

Disability Pension: Para 6 of BPS memorandum can be added in Chapter VIII

Dearness Relief: Para 7: Already covered amply in our memorandum

Additional Pension: Para 8 already covered

Para 9 also already covered

Para 11 A and 11 b of BPS memorandum on commutation: should be added to our memorandum under chapter VI under Para 6.5

Para 11 Retirees on or after 2006  may be added in our memorandum

Para 12 need not be included

Para 13 medical facilities already included

Para 16 of BPS memorandum on BSNL Pensioners to be added in our common memorandum – The suggestion of DG that same fitment benefit recommended by CPC for CG Pensioners should automatically be applied to BSNL pensioners who are also covered under CCS Pension Rules.

Para 17 Railway sectional memorandum can cover that and we need not include in common memorandum like RELH etc.

CPF / SRPF Retirees issues as in BPS memorandum under Para 17 (vi): Need not be part of common memorandum

Para 22 of BPS memorandum: Representation in various committees: no need to include.

Memorandum by AI BSNL PWA:

Para 2.5:Add one sentence at the last as narrated by the above organisation

Para 2.5: Correction: 2014-25 should be corrected as 2024-25

Para 2.8: Addition suggested is accepted:

Para 2.8: correction: the should be removed and replaced by of in line 13.

D.Gopalakrishnan wanted the table for family pensioners should be worked out for correctness.

S.K.Vyas: 8.4 Para: we will add one line that this table will not apply in case of family pensioners while they are drawing the enhanced pension.

Memorandum by AIBDPA:
A copy of memorandum as prepared by AIBDPA was supplied by Comrade C.K.Narasihman and he said that the stand of his organisation is that regarding fitment formula for BSNL pensioners is that Central Government fitment formula will not be beneficial and also not logical.
S.K.Vyas said that the view points of AIBDPA will also be included for other issues and as far as the issue on which there is difference between the AIBDPA and AI BSNL PWA, those issues can be taken up in their respective Sectional Memorandums.

Memorandum of AIRRF:

Some suggestions from meeting:

Para 8.9: reference to serving employees for death relief to be removed.

Kerala CGPA Memorandum: Grant of Festival Allowance to be added in our memorandum.

Memorandum by AIBDPA sent by Com.Jayaraj will be included.

Vyas concluding: We have agreed major points. We could not agree to some points. My approach is always that we should raise limited fundamental issues before the pay commission. But unfortunately with my views is not shared by most of our comrades; if we concentrate on some specific issues then some serious consideration is possible. But unfortunately this view is not shared by many. The major things are there in the memorandum should be:

1. Scrapping the New Pension Scheme and PFRDA.
2. Parity of Pension between the past and future pensioners.
3. Periodical revision of pension once in 5 years in future.
4. Minimum pension should not be less than the minimum pay of the lowest cadre at any point of time.
5. Quantum of pension @ 67% of the Last Pay Drawn or 10 months average whichever is greater and additional pension for older pensioners.
6. Comprehensive cashless as well as hassle-free Medicare scheme for all pensioners without any discrimination.

All other points are not as significant as like these 6 issues. If we crowd the memorandum then there is a tendency to dilute our major points by the pay commission. Will you permit to remove the fab from the memorandum and concentrate sincerely on major issues and educate our members about our approach?

These suggestions were agreed to by the entire house. The meeting ended with the vote of thanks to the Chair and to the host organisation “All India Postal & RMS Pensioners Association”.